Why does PCOS exist? The theory that it helped our ancestors survive

Why Does PCOS Exist? – The evolution theory

PCOS affects one in eight women worldwide, which is surprisingly common for something that lowers fertility. Evolutionary scientists have some fascinating explanations.

By the Care for PCOS Editorial TeamUpdated 6 min readChecked against the 2023 International PCOS Guideline
Key takeaways
  • PCOS is an evolutionary puzzle: it lowers fertility, yet it’s very common and appears worldwide at similar rates.
  • Shared genetic risk across populations suggests PCOS-related genes were present in our ancestors before humans migrated out of Africa.
  • Leading theories propose that PCOS-linked traits, such as efficient fat storage and higher testosterone, may once have helped survival during famine and hardship.
  • These are hypotheses, not proven facts, but they reframe PCOS as a mismatch between ancient biology and the modern environment, not a personal failing.

The evolutionary puzzle

Natural selection usually weeds out traits that reduce fertility. So why is PCOS one of the most common hormone conditions, affecting around 1 in 8 women? Researchers argue it should have faded over thousands of generations, unless PCOS-related traits offered some benefit in the past.

A clue: PCOS appears at broadly similar rates across very different populations, and studies have found shared genetic risk regions in Chinese and European women. That suggests the genetic risk factors were already present in human ancestors before they migrated out of Africa.

Theory 1: built for famine

One leading idea is that PCOS reflects an ancient metabolic survival adaptation. Traits linked to PCOS, such as insulin resistance and a tendency to store fat efficiently, especially around the abdomen, would have been an advantage when food was scarce and unpredictable. Fat stores and insulin resistance help keep energy flowing to the brain and muscles during “fight or flight” stress.

Lab research supports part of this: fat stem cells from normal-weight women with PCOS show exaggerated fat storage. Some researchers also suggest that fewer, more widely spaced pregnancies may have improved survival for both mothers and children in harsh times.

In today’s world of constant food availability and less physical activity, the same traits tip into weight gain, diabetes risk and irregular ovulation. This is called an evolutionary mismatch.

Theory 2: the strength advantage

A 2024 overview of systematic reviews tested another idea: that relatively higher testosterone brought benefits to women in some ancestral settings, including greater strength, muscularity, bone density and robustness. The authors found this hypothesis was largely supported by the evidence. Importantly, they don’t argue PCOS itself is adaptive. Rather, PCOS may be a “maladaptive extreme” of traits that were useful in moderation.

Theory 3: no benefit needed

Not all scientists think PCOS must have had an advantage. One review argued PCOS may have spread mainly through non-adaptive processes, such as genetic drift as small groups migrated, and genes that benefit men while causing problems in women (“sexually antagonistic selection”). For example, PCOS-related genes in male relatives may be linked to traits such as early balding and metabolic changes.

Why this matters for you

  • It’s not your fault. PCOS is rooted in deep genetic history. It isn’t caused by laziness or poor choices.
  • It explains the struggle. A body built to conserve energy finds weight loss harder in a modern food environment.
  • It points to solutions. Many effective PCOS strategies, like regular movement, building muscle, whole foods and good sleep, recreate aspects of the environment our bodies evolved for.

A gentle reminder for hard days: the traits behind PCOS may well have helped your ancestors survive. Your body isn’t broken. It’s working with ancient instructions in a very new world.

The “evolutionary mismatch” idea, explained simply

Imagine a body designed to survive famine: it stores energy efficiently, holds onto fat when food is scarce, and doesn’t waste resources on pregnancy when times are hard. In an environment of food shortages and constant physical work, those traits could be helpful.

Now put that same body in a world of ultra-processed food, desk jobs and constant stress. The same tendencies can tip into:

  • weight gain, especially around the middle
  • insulin resistance and higher diabetes risk
  • more androgen production, driven by high insulin
  • irregular ovulation

Scientists call this an “evolutionary mismatch”: a trait that suited our ancestors’ environment becomes a problem in a very different modern one.

What supports the theories, and what doesn’t

EvidenceWhat it suggests
PCOS appears at broadly similar rates worldwideIts genetic roots are likely ancient and shared across populations
Shared genetic risk regions in different ancestriesRisk genes probably predate human migration out of Africa
Higher-testosterone traits linked with strength and bone densitySupports the idea that moderate androgen levels had benefits
Lab studies of fat cells in women with PCOSConsistent with an enhanced capacity to store energy
Direct evidence from ancient populationsVery limited, because PCOS can’t be seen in skeletons, so the theories remain hard to prove

PCOS genes in men

PCOS runs in families, and its effects aren’t limited to women. Studies have found that brothers and fathers of women with PCOS may have higher rates of metabolic problems, such as insulin resistance and unfavourable cholesterol, and possibly early balding. This supports the idea that PCOS-related genes may have been passed on partly through male relatives, who wouldn’t experience the fertility effects.

Turning the theory into practice

You can’t change your genes, but you can change the environment they respond to. The most effective PCOS habits mimic aspects of the life our bodies evolved for:

  • Move throughout the day: walking, carrying, lifting. See the best exercise for PCOS.
  • Eat mostly whole foods: vegetables, legumes, whole grains, fruit, nuts and protein. See the PCOS diet guide.
  • Protect your sleep and get daylight in the morning.
  • Manage stress through connection, time outdoors and rest.
  • Use modern medicine where it helps. That’s one advantage our ancestors didn’t have.

Frequently asked questions

Is PCOS genetic?

Yes, PCOS runs strongly in families, and multiple genetic risk regions have been identified. Environment, including diet, activity and exposures before birth, also influences whether and how it shows up.

Did PCOS really help our ancestors survive?

It’s a plausible and actively researched hypothesis, but not proven. Some scientists think PCOS-linked traits were beneficial in the past, while others think non-adaptive processes explain its spread.

How old is PCOS?

Genetic evidence suggests PCOS risk genes predate human migration out of Africa, which happened tens of thousands of years ago.

Is PCOS becoming more common?

More people are being diagnosed, partly because of better awareness and broader diagnostic criteria. Rising rates of obesity and inactivity may also make PCOS features more likely to show up in people who are genetically susceptible.

Can PCOS be passed to my children?

PCOS runs in families, so daughters of women with PCOS have a higher chance of developing it, and sons may have a higher risk of metabolic problems. Healthy family habits can help reduce that risk.

Sources

  1. Bushell A, Crespi BJ. The evolutionary basis of elevated testosterone in women with PCOS: an overview of systematic reviews. Frontiers in Reproductive Health, 2024.
  2. Review of possible adaptive and non-adaptive explanations for the evolutionary paradox of PCOS (PubMed 27243467), 2016.
  3. Dumesic DA, et al. An evolutionary model for the ancient origins of polycystic ovary syndrome. Journal of Clinical Medicine, 2023.
  4. Ünlütürk U, et al. Evolutionary determinants of polycystic ovary syndrome. Fertility and Sterility (Fertile Dialogue).

Keep reading

Our complete guide: What is PCOS? The complete beginner’s guide

This guide is general information, not personal medical advice. Talk to your doctor before starting, stopping or changing any treatment or supplement. Read our medical disclaimer.